Contents 1 How to list a dispute 1.1 Instructions 1.2 Active disagreements 2 Providing third opinions 3 Declining requests


How to list a dispute[edit] Before making a request here, be sure that the issue has been thoroughly discussed on the article talk page. 3O is only for assistance in resolving disagreements that have come to a standstill. If no agreement can be reached on the talk page and only two editors are involved, follow the directions below to list the dispute. Otherwise, please follow other methods in the dispute resolution process such as the dispute resolution noticeboard or request for comment. 3O is usually flexible by allowing a few exceptions, like those involving mainly two editors with an extra editor having minimal participation. Further guidance is available in Third Opinion frequently asked questions. It is recommended that the filing editor notifies the second editor about the post here. If the second editor disagrees with this process, the first editor still has the right to receive a third opinion; however, since this is non-binding, the second editor is free to ignore the third opinion if they wish to. In cases involving long discussions or topics requiring prior technical knowledge, editors are requested to present a short summary of the dispute, in plain English and preferably in a new subsection below the main discussion, so that 3O volunteers may find it easier to respond to. Some disputes may involve editor conduct issues as well as issues regarding article content. In such cases, the third opinion request should be framed in terms of content issues, even if the conduct of an editor is also at issue. For disputes that are exclusively about an editor's conduct and are not related to a content issue, other forums may be more appropriate such as the administrators noticeboard. If in doubt, post your request here at third opinion and a neutral editor will help out. Instructions[edit] No discussion of the issue should take place here – this page is only for listing the dispute. Please confine discussion to the talk page where the dispute is taking place. Follow these instructions to make your post: Edit the following "Active disagreements" section on this page to begin a new entry in the section. Your entry should be at the end of the list if there are other entries, and the first character should be a # symbol to create a numbered list. This preserves the numbering and chronological order of the list. Your entry should contain the following: a section link to a section on the article's talk page dedicated to the 3O discussion. a brief neutral description of the dispute – no more than a line or two, and without trying to argue for or against either side. Take care (as much as possible) to make it seem as though the request is being added by both participants. a date, but no signature. You can add the date without your name by using five tildes (~~~~~). (Note: your name will still be shown in your contributions and edit history.) Requests are subject to being removed from the list if no volunteer chooses to provide an opinion within six days after they are listed below. If your dispute is removed for that reason (check the history to see the reason), please feel free to re-list your dispute if you still would like to obtain an opinion—indicate that it's been re-listed in your entry. If removed a second time due to no volunteer giving an opinion, please do not relist again. Active disagreements[edit] After reading the above instructions, add your dispute to this section, below this message. If you provide a third opinion, please remove the entry from this list. Example entry # [[Talk:Turnitin#Copyright infringement in countries where fair use does not exist]]. Disagreement about relevance of section and sources. ~~~~~ Talk:Subbotniks#Karaimites Disagreement about whether or not the Encyclopædia of Religion and Ethics should be treated as a reliable source for the correct spelling of the Russian word Karaimiti (Караимиты) in English as Karaimites (Volume 7) and as a distinct sect from Karaites (Volume 13) in the absence of any more modern scholarship on the matter in English. Russian sources on the distinction are clear and abundant but this is an article on English wikipedia so the disagreement is derived from the lack of English language sources on the matter. 10:43, 16 February 2018 (UTC)


Providing third opinions[edit] Third opinions must be neutral. If you have had dealings with the article or with the editors involved in the dispute that would bias your response, do not offer a third opinion on that dispute. Read the arguments of the disputants. Do not provide opinions recklessly. Remember that Wikipedia works by consensus, not a vote. In some cases both sides may have presented valid arguments, or you may disagree with both. Provide the reasoning behind your argument. Provide third opinions in the relevant section of the disputed article talk pages following the discussion of the dispute. Sign your comments with four tildes, like so: ~~~~. The {{3OR}} template is handy for inserting a third opinion on the talk page. For a shorter alternative, {{3ORshort}} can also be used. Usage: {{subst:3OR | <your response> }} or {{subst:3ORshort | <your response> }}. Write your opinion in a civil and nonjudgmental way. Consider keeping pages on which you have given a third opinion on your watchlist for a few days. Often, articles listed here are watched by very few people. If it's not clear what the dispute is, put {{subst:third opinion|your_username}} on the talk page of the article. This template will post sections for the disputing editors to summarize their opinions. For third opinion requests that do not follow the instructions above, it is possible to alert the requesting party to that fact by employing {{uw-3o}}. When providing a third opinion, please remove the listing from this page before you provide your third opinion. Doing so prevents other volunteers from duplicating your effort. Mention in the summary which dispute you have removed and how many remain. Respondents appreciate feedback about the outcome of the dispute, either on the article's talk page or on their own talk page. We want to know whether the outcome was positive or not, helping us to maintain and improve the standards of our work. If a respondent's third opinion was especially helpful or wise, you might want to consider awarding {{subst:The Third Opinion Award|your message}} on their user talk page. It can also be given once for diligent service to this project which is generally any volunteer who has more than 50 edits to this page. For more information see its documentation and Wikipedia:Third opinion/Service award log. Adding {{Wikipedia:Third opinion}} to your dashboard or userpage will produce or transclude only the active disagreements for viewing. Sample code with additional links: Third opinion disputes {{Wikipedia:Third Opinion}}<small>[{{fullurl:Wikipedia:Third opinion|action=edit&section=3}} update], {{purge}}</small> Active contributors who watchlist the page, review disputes, and update the list of active disagreements with informative edit summaries, are welcome to add themselves to the Category:Wikipedians willing to provide third opinions. If you support this project you may wish to add the {{User Third opinion}} userbox to your user page, which automatically adds you to this category.


Declining requests[edit] If you remove a dispute from the list for any reason, it is good practice to also leave a message on the dispute talk page explaining what you have done. The message should: Be civil and assume the request was made in good faith. Explain why the request was declined (e.g. "There are too many people involved already.") Suggest alternatives (e.g. "Perhaps you should try WP:Requests for Comment, the dispute resolution noticeboard, the talk page of a Wikiproject or one of the other WP:Dispute resolution options.") Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Third_opinion&oldid=826027538" Categories: Wikipedia dispute resolution


Navigation menu Personal tools Not logged inTalkContributionsCreate accountLog in Namespaces Project pageTalk Variants Views ReadEditView history More Search Navigation Main pageContentsFeatured contentCurrent eventsRandom articleDonate to WikipediaWikipedia store Interaction HelpAbout WikipediaCommunity portalRecent changesContact page Tools What links hereRelated changesUpload fileSpecial pagesPermanent linkPage informationWikidata item Print/export Create a bookDownload as PDFPrintable version Languages العربيةČeštinaDeutschفارسیÍslenskaPortuguêsSvenskaTürkçe Edit links This page was last edited on 16 February 2018, at 19:54. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. Privacy policy About Wikipedia Disclaimers Contact Wikipedia Developers Cookie statement Mobile view (window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgPageParseReport":{"limitreport":{"cputime":"0.064","walltime":"0.102","ppvisitednodes":{"value":553,"limit":1000000},"ppgeneratednodes":{"value":0,"limit":1500000},"postexpandincludesize":{"value":21422,"limit":2097152},"templateargumentsize":{"value":2788,"limit":2097152},"expansiondepth":{"value":10,"limit":40},"expensivefunctioncount":{"value":5,"limit":500},"entityaccesscount":{"value":0,"limit":400},"timingprofile":["100.00% 80.954 1 -total"," 51.80% 41.938 1 Template:Ombox"," 27.71% 22.436 1 Template:Redirect3"," 23.87% 19.322 1 Template:Hatnote"," 19.42% 15.718 1 Template:Ombox/shortcut"," 16.18% 13.101 1 Template:Dispute-resolution"," 15.34% 12.422 4 Template:Nowrap"," 13.89% 11.243 1 Template:Helpbox"," 13.15% 10.642 4 Template:No_redirect"," 9.67% 7.826 1 Template:Sidebar"]},"scribunto":{"limitreport-timeusage":{"value":"0.022","limit":"10.000"},"limitreport-memusage":{"value":1269835,"limit":52428800}},"cachereport":{"origin":"mw1283","timestamp":"20180216195423","ttl":1900800,"transientcontent":false}}});});(window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgBackendResponseTime":73,"wgHostname":"mw1268"});});


Wikipedia:Third_opinion - Photos and All Basic Informations

Wikipedia:Third_opinion More Links

Wikipedia:TrifectaWikipedia:Triple CrownWikipedia:Three-revert RuleWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Dispute Resolution RequestsWikipedia:Assume Good FaithWikipedia:EtiquetteWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:NegotiationWikipedia:Talk Page GuidelinesWikipedia:Responding To A Failure To DiscussWikipedia:Editor AssistanceWikipedia:Dispute Resolution NoticeboardWikipedia:Dispute Resolution Noticeboard/requestWikipedia:Requests For CommentWikipedia:Requests For CommentWikipedia:Mediation CommitteeWikipedia:Requests For MediationWikipedia:Administrators' Noticeboard/IncidentsWikipedia:Arbitration CommitteeWikipedia:Arbitration/RequestsTemplate:Dispute-resolutionTemplate Talk:Dispute-resolutionWikipedia:Assume Good FaithWikipedia:CIVILWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Dispute Resolution NoticeboardWikipedia:RFCWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Dispute Resolution NoticeboardWikipedia:RFCWikipedia:Third Opinion/User FAQWikipedia:Plain EnglishWikipedia:ANINumber SignHelp:SectionTalk:SubbotniksEncyclopædia Of Religion And EthicsWikipedia:Neutral Point Of ViewWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:VoteTemplate:3ORTemplate:3ORshortWikipedia:CivilityHelp:Watching PagesTemplate:Third OpinionTemplate:Uw-3oTemplate:The Third Opinion AwardWikipedia:Third Opinion/Service Award LogCategory:Wikipedians Willing To Provide Third OpinionsTemplate:User Third OpinionWikipedia:Requests For CommentWikipedia:DRNWikipedia:WikiProjectWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionHelp:CategoryCategory:Wikipedia Dispute ResolutionDiscussion About Edits From This IP Address [n]A List Of Edits Made From This IP Address [y]View The Project Page [c]Discussion About The Content Page [t]Edit This Page [e]Visit The Main Page [z]Guides To Browsing WikipediaFeatured Content – The Best Of WikipediaFind Background Information On Current EventsLoad A Random Article [x]Guidance On How To Use And Edit WikipediaFind Out About WikipediaAbout The Project, What You Can Do, Where To Find ThingsA List Of Recent Changes In The Wiki [r]List Of All English Wikipedia Pages Containing Links To This Page [j]Recent Changes In Pages Linked From This Page [k]Upload Files [u]A List Of All Special Pages [q]Wikipedia:AboutWikipedia:General Disclaimer



view link view link view link view link view link