Contents 1 Types of ownership 1.1 Single-editor ownership 1.2 Multiple-editor ownership 2 Ownership and stewardship 2.1 Featured articles 3 User pages 4 Resolving ownership issues 5 Examples of ownership behaviour 5.1 Actions 5.2 Statements 6 See also 7 External links


Types of ownership[edit] There are two common types of ownership conflicts between users: those involving one editor and those involving multiple editors. While ownership behavior is often understood to involve the original creator of the article, it can also involve other editors who have conflicting interests in promoting or opposing the subject, hijacking the original article's direction and emphasis, changing the title to reflect such changes, or, if unsuccessful, actually deleting the article as a form of revenge. Single-editor ownership[edit] In many cases (but not all), single editors engaged in ownership conflicts are also primary contributors to the article, so keep in mind that such editors may be experts in their field or have a genuine interest in maintaining the quality of the article and preserving accuracy. An editor who appears to assume ownership of an article should be approached on the article's talk page with a descriptive header informing readers about the topic. Always avoid accusations, attacks, and speculations concerning the motivation of any editor. If the behaviour continues, the issue may require dispute resolution, but it is important to make a good attempt to communicate with the editor on the article talk page before proceeding to mediation, etc. Editors of this type often welcome discussion, so a simple exchange of ideas will usually solve the problem of ownership. If you find that the editor continues to be hostile, makes personal attacks, or wages edit wars, try to ignore disruptive editing by discussing the topic on the talk page. You may need to ignore attacks made in response to a query. If ownership persists after a discussion, dispute resolution may be necessary, but at least you will be on record as having attempted to solve the problem directly with the editor. It is important to make a good attempt to communicate with the editor on the article talk page before proceeding to mediation, etc. It may also be wise to allow them to withdraw from the conversation and return when they are ready. Multiple-editor ownership[edit] The involvement of multiple editors, each defending the ownership of the other, can be highly complex. The simplest scenario usually consists of a dominant editor who is defended by other editors, reinforcing the former's ownership. This is often informally described as a tag team, and can be frustrating to both new and seasoned editors. As before, address the topic and not the actions of the editors. If this fails, proceed to dispute resolution, but it is important to communicate on the talk page and attempt to resolve the dispute yourself before escalating the conflict resolution process.


Ownership and stewardship[edit] Shortcuts WP:OAS WP:STEWARDSHIP "WP:STEWARDSHIP" redirects here. For the group of users, see meta:Stewards. Do not confuse stewardship with ownership. Stewardship of an article (or group of related articles) may be the result of a sincere personal interest in the subject matter or an interest in a cause or organization related to the article's subject matter. The editor might also be an expert on the subject matter, or otherwise very knowledgeable of the topic, and able to provide credible insights for locating reliable sources. If any of this is the case, the editor(s) in question is/are no less responsible for adhering to core policies like WP:Neutral point of view, citing reliable sources, or civility. But unless an editor exhibits behaviour associated with ownership, it's best to assume good faith on their part. Wikipedia is the encyclopedia that "anyone can edit", but not all edits bring improvement. In many cases, a core group of editors will have worked to build the article up to its present state, and will revert edits that they find detrimental in order, they believe, to preserve the quality of the encyclopedia. Such reversion does not indicate an "ownership" problem, if it is supported by an edit summary referring to Wikipedia policies and guidelines, previous reviews and discussions, or specific grammar or prose problems introduced by the edit. Where disagreement persists after such a reversion, the editor proposing the change should first take the matter to the talk page, without personal comments or accusations of ownership. In this way, the specifics of any change can be discussed with the editors who are familiar with the article, who are likewise expected to discuss the content civilly. This is in keeping with the BRD cycle, which stands for bold, revert, discuss. Though not an official guideline or policy, it is a dependable method for conflict resolution. Featured articles[edit] While Featured articles (identified by a bronze star in the upper-right corner ) are open for editing like any other, they have gone through a community review process as Featured article candidates, where they are checked for high-quality sources, a thorough survey of the relevant literature, and compliance with the Featured Article criteria. Editors are asked to take particular care when editing a Featured article; it is considerate to discuss significant changes of text or images on the talk page first. Explaining civilly why sources and policies support a particular version of a featured article does not necessarily constitute ownership. The {{article history}} template on the talk page will contain a link to the Featured article candidacy and any subsequent Featured article reviews. Good articles (identified by a green circle in the upper-right corner ) have gone through a lighter peer review process than Featured articles, generally by two editors, to check basic requirements of prose, factual accuracy, and scope. All editors are welcome to make changes and improve the article, but some discussion of significant changes is recommended, and the editors participating in the review may be able to offer advice and work with you on improving the article further.


User pages[edit] Main pages: Wikipedia:User pages and Wikipedia:Talk page guidelines § User talk pages Wikipedia offers wide latitude to users to manage their user space as they see fit. Nevertheless, they are not personal homepages, and are not owned by the user. They are part of Wikipedia and must serve its primary purposes; in particular, user talk pages make communication and collaboration among editors easier. These functions must not be hampered by ownership behavior. While other users and bots will more commonly edit your user talk page, they have rights to edit other pages in your user space as well. Usually others will not edit your user page itself, other than to address significant concerns (rarely) or to do routine housekeeping, such as handling project-related tags, disambiguating links to pages that have been moved, removing the page from categories meant for articles, or removing obvious vandalism and/or BLP violations.


Resolving ownership issues[edit] While it may be easy to identify ownership issues, it is far more difficult to resolve the conflict to the satisfaction of the editors involved. It is always helpful to remember to stay calm, assume good faith, and remain civil. Accusing other editors of owning the article may appear aggressive, and could be perceived as a personal attack. Address the editor in a civil manner, with the same amount of respect you would expect. Often, editors accused of ownership may not even realize it, so it is important to assume good faith. Some editors may think they are protecting the article from vandalism, and may respond to any changes with hostility. Others may try to promote their own point of view, failing to recognize the importance of the neutrality policy.


Examples of ownership behaviour[edit] If an editor consistently demonstrates behavior similar to that shown in the following examples in a certain article talk page, then they probably have issues with page ownership. Shortcut WP:OWNBEHAVIOR Further information: Wikipedia:No personal attacks Actions[edit] An editor disputes minor edits concerning layout, image use, and wording in a particular article daily. The editor might claim, whether openly or implicitly, the right to review any changes before they can be added to the article. (This does not include the routine maintenance of article consistency, such as preservation of established spelling or citation styles.) An editor reverts justified article changes by different editors repeatedly over an extended period to protect a certain version, stable or not. An editor reverts a change simply because the editor finds it "unnecessary" without claiming that the change is detrimental. This has the effect of assigning priority, between two equivalent versions, to an owner's version. An editor reverts a good-faith change without providing an edit summary that refers to relevant Wikipedia policies and guidelines, previous reviews and discussions, reliable sources, or specific grammar or prose problems introduced by the edit. Repeating such no-reason reversions after being asked for a rationale is a strong indicator of ownership behavior. An editor comments on other editors' talk pages with the purpose of discouraging them from making additional contributions. The discussion can take many forms; it may be purely negative, consisting of threats and insults, often avoiding the topic of the article altogether. At the other extreme, the owner may patronize other editors, claiming that their ideas are interesting while also claiming that they lack the deep understanding of the subject necessary to edit the article (see the first two comments in the Statements section just below). Sometimes a newcomer puts his or her name into the article as the author. Since no one "owns" any Wikipedia content, content should not be signed. The exact contributions of all editors are seen with their names on the page history. On the other hand, when adding comments, questions, or votes to talk pages, it is good to "own" your text, so the best practice is to sign it by suffixing your entry with "~~~~". Statements[edit] Although the following statements, seen in isolation from any context or other statements, do not indicate ownership behavior or motivation, they may be part of a pattern that indicates ownership behavior. When they occur along with some form of dogged insistence and relentless pushing, without good policy back up, and often including edit warring, they may be an expression of ownership behavior. "Are you qualified to edit this article?" "You obviously have no hands-on experience with this topic." "I created/wrote the majority of this article." (Implying some kind of right or status exists because of that.) "I saw your edit to this article, and I appreciate your enthusiasm; however, I am an expert on the subject, and for the accuracy of this article, I have reverted your edit. If you have any suggestions, please put them in the talk page and I will review them." "If Bob disagrees with your view that a given source is reliable, then it's clearly unreliable, isn't it?" (Multiple-editor ownership.) "Please clear this with WikiProject Z first." "Undo peanut-gallery editor." "I can see nothing wrong with the article and there is no need to change anything at all." "Do not make such changes or comments until you have significantly edited or written work of this quality." "Unless it is wrong or has errors, please do not make such changes or comments without my/his/her/our approval." "You didn't have consensus because I was offline." "I haven't had time to confirm what you wrote. I have other obligations besides Wikipedia, you know." "I don't own that book, so I can't confirm your source." "I have spent hours editing this article. You are vandalizing my work!" "You hadn't edited the article or talk page previously as a history search shows." "I left Wikipedia for a good part of the year because the development and promotional/advocacy tone of this article so disgusted me."


See also[edit] Wikipedia:Consensus#Levels of consensus


External links[edit] AuthorshipModel—a discussion of authorship of Wiki pages on the CommunityWiki (retrieved December 29 2014) v t e Wikipedia key policies and guidelines Five pillars What Wikipedia is not Ignore all rules Content Verifiability No original research Neutral point of view What Wikipedia is not Biographies of living persons Image use Wikipedia is not a dictionary Article titles Notability Autobiography Citing sources Identifying reliable sources medicine Do not include copies of primary sources Plagiarism Don't create hoaxes Fringe theories Patent nonsense External links Conduct Civility Consensus Editing policy Harassment Vandalism Ignore all rules No personal attacks Ownership of content Edit warring Dispute resolution Sock puppetry No legal threats Child protection Paid-contribution disclosure Assume good faith Conflict of interest Disruptive editing Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point Etiquette Gaming the system Please do not bite the newcomers Courtesy vanishing Deletion Deletion policy Proposed deletion Criteria for speedy deletion Attack page Oversight Proposed deletion of BLP Proposed deletion (books) Revision deletion Enforcement Administrators Banning Blocking Page protection Editing Article size Be bold Disambiguation Hatnotes Set index articles Subpages User pages Talk page guidelines Signatures Broad-concept article Project namespace WikiProjects Style Manual of Style Contents Accessibility Understandability Dates and numbers Images Layout Lead section Linking Lists Classification Categories, lists, and navigation templates Categorization Template namespace WMF List of policies Friendly space policy Licensing and copyright Privacy policy Values FAQ List of all policies and guidelines List of policies List of guidelines Lists of attempts in creating fundamental principles Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Ownership_of_content&oldid=823435702" Categories: Wikipedia policiesWikipedia conduct policiesWikipedia cultureHidden categories: Wikipedia move-protected project pages


Navigation menu Personal tools Not logged inTalkContributionsCreate accountLog in Namespaces Project pageTalk Variants Views ReadEditView history More Search Navigation Main pageContentsFeatured contentCurrent eventsRandom articleDonate to WikipediaWikipedia store Interaction HelpAbout WikipediaCommunity portalRecent changesContact page Tools What links hereRelated changesUpload fileSpecial pagesPermanent linkPage informationWikidata item Print/export Create a bookDownload as PDFPrintable version In other projects Wikimedia CommonsWikibooks Languages Alemannischالعربيةঅসমীয়াتۆرکجهবাংলাБългарскиBrezhonegČeštinaDeutschEspañolفارسیFrançaisGalego한국어HrvatskiBahasa IndonesiaÍslenskaעבריתҚазақшаLietuviųMagyarМакедонскиമലയാളംBahasa Melayu日本語PolskiPortuguêsРусскийසිංහලSimple EnglishکوردیСрпски / srpskiSrpskohrvatski / српскохрватскиSuomiSvenskaТатарча/tatarçaไทยTürkçeاردوTiếng Việt中文 Edit links This page was last edited on 1 February 2018, at 06:19. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. Privacy policy About Wikipedia Disclaimers Contact Wikipedia Developers Cookie statement Mobile view (window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgPageParseReport":{"limitreport":{"cputime":"0.132","walltime":"0.207","ppvisitednodes":{"value":847,"limit":1000000},"ppgeneratednodes":{"value":0,"limit":1500000},"postexpandincludesize":{"value":80286,"limit":2097152},"templateargumentsize":{"value":1528,"limit":2097152},"expansiondepth":{"value":9,"limit":40},"expensivefunctioncount":{"value":7,"limit":500},"entityaccesscount":{"value":0,"limit":400},"timingprofile":["100.00% 140.025 1 -total"," 34.23% 47.934 1 Template:Policy"," 32.41% 45.385 1 Template:Ombox"," 23.37% 32.727 8 Template:Navbox"," 16.61% 23.255 3 Template:Shortcut"," 16.24% 22.745 1 Template:Wikipedia_policies_and_guidelines"," 10.73% 15.025 1 Template:Pp-move-indef"," 9.11% 12.762 1 Template:Conduct_policy_list"," 8.20% 11.484 1 Template:Helpbox"," 7.99% 11.184 1 Template:About"]},"scribunto":{"limitreport-timeusage":{"value":"0.055","limit":"10.000"},"limitreport-memusage":{"value":2682109,"limit":52428800}},"cachereport":{"origin":"mw1273","timestamp":"20180219030652","ttl":1900800,"transientcontent":false}}});});(window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgBackendResponseTime":71,"wgHostname":"mw1332"});});


Wikipedia:Ownership_of_content - Photos and All Basic Informations

Wikipedia:Ownership_of_content More Links

Wikipedia:CopyrightsWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:What "Ignore All Rules" MeansWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:List Of PoliciesWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:Clean StartWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Edit WarringWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:HarassmentWikipedia:Non-discrimination PolicyWikipedia:No Personal AttacksWikipedia:Sock PuppetryWikipedia:Username PolicyWikipedia:VandalismTemplate:Conduct Policy ListTemplate Talk:Conduct Policy ListWikipediaWikipedia:Conflict Of InterestWikipedia:Avoiding Common MistakesWikipedia:Edit WarringWikipedia:Resolving DisputesWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:EtiquetteWikipedia:Assume Good FaithWikipedia:Edit WarWikipedia:Disruptive EditingWikipedia:DRWikipedia:Tag TeamWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:GFWikipedia:RSWikipedia:Neutral Point Of ViewWikipedia:CITEWikipedia:RSWikipedia:CIVILWikipedia:GFWikipedia:NPAWikipedia:BRDWikipedia:GUIDELINEWikipedia:FAWikipedia:FACWikipedia:Featured Article CriteriaTemplate:Article HistoryWikipedia:FARWikipedia:GAEdit Section: User PagesWikipedia:User PagesWikipedia:Talk Page GuidelinesWikipedia:NamespaceHelp:Using Talk PagesWikipedia:BLPWikipedia:COOLWikipedia:AGFWikipedia:CIVWikipedia:NPOVWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:No Personal AttacksWikipedia:ENGVARWikipedia:CITEVARWikipedia:SignaturesHelp:Page HistoryWikipedia:Sign Your Posts On Talk PagesWikipedia:ConsensusTemplate:Wikipedia Policies And GuidelinesTemplate Talk:Wikipedia Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:Five PillarsWikipedia:What Wikipedia Is NotWikipedia:Ignore All RulesWikipedia:VerifiabilityWikipedia:No Original ResearchWikipedia:Neutral Point Of ViewWikipedia:What Wikipedia Is NotWikipedia:Biographies Of Living PersonsWikipedia:Image Use PolicyWikipedia:Wikipedia Is Not A DictionaryWikipedia:Article TitlesWikipedia:NotabilityWikipedia:AutobiographyWikipedia:Citing SourcesWikipedia:Identifying Reliable SourcesWikipedia:Identifying Reliable Sources (medicine)Wikipedia:Do Not Include The Full Text Of Lengthy Primary SourcesWikipedia:PlagiarismWikipedia:Do Not Create HoaxesWikipedia:Fringe TheoriesWikipedia:Patent NonsenseWikipedia:External LinksWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:HarassmentWikipedia:VandalismWikipedia:Ignore All RulesWikipedia:No Personal AttacksWikipedia:Edit WarringWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Sock PuppetryWikipedia:No Legal ThreatsWikipedia:Child ProtectionWikipedia:Paid-contribution DisclosureWikipedia:Assume Good FaithWikipedia:Conflict Of InterestWikipedia:Disruptive EditingWikipedia:Do Not Disrupt Wikipedia To Illustrate A PointWikipedia:EtiquetteWikipedia:Gaming The SystemWikipedia:Please Do Not Bite The NewcomersWikipedia:Courtesy VanishingWikipedia:Deletion PolicyWikipedia:Proposed DeletionWikipedia:Criteria For Speedy DeletionWikipedia:Attack PageWikipedia:OversightWikipedia:Proposed Deletion Of Biographies Of Living PeopleWikipedia:Proposed Deletion (books)Wikipedia:Revision DeletionWikipedia:AdministratorsWikipedia:Banning PolicyWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:Protection PolicyWikipedia:Article SizeWikipedia:Be BoldWikipedia:DisambiguationWikipedia:HatnoteWikipedia:Set Index ArticlesWikipedia:SubpagesWikipedia:User PagesWikipedia:Talk Page GuidelinesWikipedia:SignaturesWikipedia:Broad-concept ArticleWikipedia:Project NamespaceWikipedia:WikiProject Council/GuideWikipedia:Manual Of StyleWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ContentsWikipedia:Manual Of Style/AccessibilityWikipedia:Make Technical Articles UnderstandableWikipedia:Manual Of Style/Dates And NumbersWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ImagesWikipedia:Manual Of Style/LayoutWikipedia:Manual Of Style/Lead SectionWikipedia:Manual Of Style/LinkingWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ListsWikipedia:Categories, Lists, And Navigation TemplatesWikipedia:CategorizationWikipedia:Template NamespaceWikipedia:List Of Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:List Of PoliciesWikipedia:List Of GuidelinesWikipedia:PrinciplesHelp:CategoryCategory:Wikipedia PoliciesCategory:Wikipedia Conduct PoliciesCategory:Wikipedia CultureCategory:Wikipedia Move-protected Project PagesDiscussion About Edits From This IP Address [n]A List Of Edits Made From This IP Address [y]View The Project Page [c]Discussion About The Content Page [t]Edit This Page [e]Visit The Main Page [z]Guides To Browsing WikipediaFeatured Content – The Best Of WikipediaFind Background Information On Current EventsLoad A Random Article [x]Guidance On How To Use And Edit WikipediaFind Out About WikipediaAbout The Project, What You Can Do, Where To Find ThingsA List Of Recent Changes In The Wiki [r]List Of All English Wikipedia Pages Containing Links To This Page [j]Recent Changes In Pages Linked From This Page [k]Upload Files [u]A List Of All Special Pages [q]Wikipedia:AboutWikipedia:General Disclaimer



view link view link view link view link view link