Contents 1 What edit warring is 1.1 The three-revert rule 1.2 Exemptions 1.3 Other revert rules 2 Handling of edit-warring behaviors 2.1 What to do if you see edit-warring behavior 2.2 How experienced editors avoid becoming involved in edit wars 3 Administrator guidance 4 See also 5 References 6 Further reading


What edit warring is Conduct policies Block evasion Civility Clean start Consensus Dispute resolution Edit warring Editing policy Harassment Non-discrimination policy No personal attacks Ownership of content Sock puppetry Username policy Vandalism v t e See also: Wikipedia:Editing policy Wikipedia encourages editors to be bold, but while a potentially controversial change may be made to find out whether it is opposed, another editor may revert it. This may be the beginning of a bold, revert, discuss (BRD) cycle. An edit war only arises if the situation develops into a series of back-and-forth reverts. Nevertheless, not every revert or controversial edit is regarded as edit warring: Reverting vandalism is not edit warring. However, edits from a slanted point of view, general insertion or removal of material, or other good-faith changes are not considered vandalism. See Wikipedia:Vandalism § Types of vandalism and Wikipedia:Vandalism § What is not vandalism. Reverting to enforce certain overriding policies is not considered edit warring. For example, under the policy on biographies of living persons, where negative unsourced content is being introduced, the risk of harm is such that removal is required. Reverting edits by banned or blocked users is not edit warring. Reverting edits in one's own user page is rarely edit warring. Traditionally, Wikipedia offers wide latitude to users to manage their user space as they see fit. For more information, see Wikipedia:User pages § Ownership and editing of user pages. When reverting, be sure to indicate your reasons. This can be done in the edit summary and/or talk page. Anti-vandalism tools such as Twinkle, Huggle and rollback should not be used to undo good-faith changes in content disputes without an appropriate edit summary. The three-revert rule Policy shortcuts WP:3RR WP:4RR Editors who engage in edit warring are liable to be blocked from editing to prevent further disruption. While any edit warring may lead to sanctions, there is a bright-line rule called the three-revert rule (3RR), the violation of which often leads to a block. The three-revert rule states: An editor must not perform more than three reverts on a single page—whether involving the same or different material—within a 24-hour period. An edit or a series of consecutive edits that undoes other editors' actions—whether in whole or in part—counts as a revert. Violations of the rule often attract blocks of at least 24 hours. Fourth reverts just outside the 24-hour period may also be taken as evidence of edit-warring, especially if repeated or combined with other edit-warring behavior. See below for exemptions. A "page" means any page on Wikipedia, including talk and project space. A "revert" means any edit (or administrative action) that reverses the actions of other editors, in whole or in part, whether involving the same or different material. A series of consecutive saved revert edits by one user with no intervening edits by another user counts as one revert. The three-revert rule applies per person, not per account; reverts made by multiple accounts operated by one editor count together. Editors violating 3RR will usually be blocked for 24 hours for a first incident. Even without a 3RR violation, an administrator may still act if they believe a user's behavior constitutes edit warring, and any user may report edit warring with or without 3RR being breached. The rule is not an entitlement to revert a page a specific number of times. If an editor violates 3RR by mistake, they should reverse their own most recent reversion. Administrators may take this into account and decide not to block in such cases—for example if the user is not a habitual edit warrior and is genuinely trying to rectify their own mistake. Exemptions Policy shortcuts WP:3RRNO WP:NOT3RR WP:3RRBLP The following reverts are exempt from the edit-warring policy: Reverting your own actions ("self-reverting"). Reverting edits to pages in your own user space, so long as you are respecting the user page guidelines. Reverting actions performed by banned users in violation of their ban, and sockpuppets of banned or blocked users. Reverting obvious vandalism—edits that any well-intentioned user would agree constitute vandalism, such as page blanking and adding offensive language. Removal of clear copyright violations or content that unquestionably violates the non-free content policy (NFCC). What counts as exempt under NFCC can be controversial, and should be established as a violation first. Consider reporting to the Wikipedia:Files for discussion noticeboard instead of relying on this exemption. Removal of other content that is clearly illegal under U.S. law, such as child pornography and links to pirated software. Removing violations of the biographies of living persons (BLP) policy that contain libelous, biased, unsourced, or poorly sourced contentious material. What counts as exempt under BLP can be controversial. Consider reporting to the BLP noticeboard instead of relying on this exemption. Considerable leeway is also given to editors reverting to maintain the quality of a featured article while it appears on the main page. If you are claiming an exemption, make sure there is a clearly visible edit summary or separate section of the talk page that explains the exemption. When in doubt, do not revert. Instead, engage in dispute resolution, and in particular ask for help at relevant noticeboards such as the Edit war/3RR noticeboard. Other revert rules Policy shortcuts WP:0RR WP:1RR Additional restrictions on reverting may be imposed by ArbCom, under administrator enforcement, or by the community (see Editing restrictions and General sanctions). These restrictions are generally called 1RR (one-revert rule) or 0RR (zero-revert rule). The one-revert rule is described like the three-revert rule above, except with the words "more than one revert" replacing "more than three reverts". Often there is also a requirement to discuss each of the reversions on the talk page, and sometimes the phrase "24-hour period" is replaced by some other time period, such as "one week" or "one month". The rule may be applied to either pages or editors. The zero-revert rule means a complete prohibition on reverts (as defined for the purpose of the three-revert rule) and is imposed on editors. Editors may also voluntarily agree to abide by a stricter reverting standard such as 1RR or 0RR, either in response to problems in a particular area, or as a general editing philosophy. For more details, see Wikipedia:Revert only when necessary.


Handling of edit-warring behaviors What to do if you see edit-warring behavior If an edit war develops, participants should try to discuss the issue on the talk page and work things out. It is better to seek help in addressing the issue than to engage in edit warring. When disagreement becomes apparent, one, both, or all participants should cease warring and discuss the issue on the associated talk page, or seek help at appropriate venues. Other alternative approaches recommended within the community are suggested below. If, despite trying, one or more users fail to cease edit warring, refuse to work collaboratively or heed the information given to them, or do not move on to appropriate dispute resolution, then a request for administrative involvement via a report at the Edit war/3RR noticeboard is the norm. A warning is not required, but if the user appears unaware that edit warring is prohibited, they can be told about this policy by posting a {{uw-3rr}} template message on their user talk page. Avoid posting a generic warning template if actively involved in the edit war; it can be seen as aggressive. Consider writing your own note to the user specifically appropriate for the situation, with a view to explicitly cooling things down. How experienced editors avoid becoming involved in edit wars This section in a nutshell: Communication is the key to avoiding conflict. Follow Wikipedia:Editing policy § Talking and editing. Shortcut WP:AVOIDEDITWAR Once it is clear there is a dispute, avoid relying solely on edit summaries and discuss the matter on the associated talk page, which is where a reviewing admin will look for evidence of trying to settle the dispute. It may help to remember that there is no deadline and that editors can add appropriate cleanup tags to problematic sections under current discussion. When discussion does not produce a conclusion, bringing wider attention to a dispute can lead to compromise. Consider getting a third opinion or starting a request for comments. Neutral editors aware of the dispute will help curb egregious edits while also building consensus about the dispute. If these methods fail, seek informal and formal dispute resolution. Some experienced editors deliberately adopt a policy of only reverting edits covered by the exceptions listed above, or limiting themselves to a single revert; if there is further dispute, they seek dialog or outside help rather than make the problem worse, i.e., they revert only when necessary. This policy may be particularly appropriate for controversial topics where views are polarized and emotions run high, resulting in more frequent edit warring. The bottom line: use common sense, and do not participate in edit wars. Rather than reverting repeatedly, discuss the matter with others; if a revert is necessary, another editor may conclude the same and do it (without you prompting them), which would then demonstrate consensus for the action. Request page protection rather than becoming part of the dispute by reverting.


Administrator guidance Administrators decide whether to issue a warning or block; these are intended to prevent, deter and encourage change in disruptive behavior, not to punish it. Where a block is appropriate, 24 hours is common for a first offense; administrators tend to issue longer blocks for repeated or aggravated violations, and will consider other factors, such as civility and previous blocks. Where multiple editors edit war or breach 3RR, administrators should consider all sides, since perceived unfairness can fuel issues. According to WP:Administrators, "Administrators should not use their tools to advantage, or in a content dispute (or article) where they are a party (or significant editor), or where a significant conflict of interest is likely to exist."


See also Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in edit wars Wikipedia:BOLD, revert, discuss cycle Wikipedia:Consensus Wikipedia:Dispute resolution Wikipedia:Disruptive editing Wikipedia:Etiquette Wikipedia:Lamest edit wars Wikipedia:Ownership of articles Wikipedia:Page-move war Help:Reverting (how-to) Wikipedia:Three-revert rule (policy) Wikipedia:Reverting (essay) Wikipedia:Alternatives to reversion (essay) Wikipedia:Baby and bathwater (essay) Wikipedia:Revert only when necessary (essay) Wikipedia:Don't shoot yourself in the foot (essay) Wikipedia:Sock puppetry Help:Talkspace draft Wikipedia:Tendentious editing


References ^ "Portal:Pope/Intro: Revision history". wikipedia.org. 


Further reading Yasseri T, Sumi R, Rung A, Kornai A, Kertész J (2012) Dynamics of Conflicts in Wikipedia. PLoS ONE 7(6): e38869. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0038869 v t e Wikipedia key policies and guidelines Five pillars What Wikipedia is not Ignore all rules Content Verifiability No original research Neutral point of view What Wikipedia is not Biographies of living persons Image use Wikipedia is not a dictionary Article titles Notability Autobiography Citing sources Identifying reliable sources medicine Do not include copies of primary sources Plagiarism Don't create hoaxes Fringe theories Patent nonsense External links Conduct Civility Consensus Editing policy Harassment Vandalism Ignore all rules No personal attacks Ownership of content Edit warring Dispute resolution Sock puppetry No legal threats Child protection Paid-contribution disclosure Assume good faith Conflict of interest Disruptive editing Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point Etiquette Gaming the system Please do not bite the newcomers Courtesy vanishing Deletion Deletion policy Proposed deletion Criteria for speedy deletion Attack page Oversight Proposed deletion of BLP Proposed deletion (books) Revision deletion Enforcement Administrators Banning Blocking Page protection Editing Article size Be bold Disambiguation Hatnotes Set index articles Subpages User pages Talk page guidelines Signatures Broad-concept article Project namespace WikiProjects Style Manual of Style Contents Accessibility Understandability Dates and numbers Images Layout Lead section Linking Lists Classification Categories, lists, and navigation templates Categorization Template namespace WMF List of policies Friendly space policy Licensing and copyright Privacy policy Values FAQ List of all policies and guidelines List of policies List of guidelines Lists of attempts in creating fundamental principles Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Edit_warring&oldid=819025803" Categories: Wikipedia policiesWikipedia:Edit warringHidden categories: Wikipedia semi-protected project pagesWikipedia move-protected project pagesArticles including recorded pronunciations (English)


Navigation menu Personal tools Not logged inTalkContributionsCreate accountLog in Namespaces Project pageTalk Variants Views ReadView sourceView history More Search Navigation Main pageContentsFeatured contentCurrent eventsRandom articleDonate to WikipediaWikipedia store Interaction HelpAbout WikipediaCommunity portalRecent changesContact page Tools What links hereRelated changesUpload fileSpecial pagesPermanent linkPage informationWikidata item Print/export Create a bookDownload as PDFPrintable version In other projects Meta-WikiWikivoyage Languages العربيةঅসমীয়াAzərbaycancaتۆرکجهবাংলাБългарскиDanskDavvisámegiellaDeutschΕλληνικάEspañolEsperantoفارسیFrançaisGalego한국어ՀայերենBahasa IndonesiaInterlinguaÍslenskaItalianoעבריתქართულიKiswahiliLietuviųMagyarМакедонскиമലയാളംBahasa MelayuNederlands日本語NorskPolskiPortuguêsРусскийShqipසිංහලSimple EnglishکوردیСрпски / srpskiSrpskohrvatski / српскохрватскиSuomiSvenskaТатарча/tatarçaไทยTürkçeУкраїнськаاردوTiếng Việtייִדיש粵語Zazaki中文 Edit links This page was last edited on 6 January 2018, at 23:52. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. Privacy policy About Wikipedia Disclaimers Contact Wikipedia Developers Cookie statement Mobile view (window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgPageParseReport":{"limitreport":{"cputime":"0.308","walltime":"0.418","ppvisitednodes":{"value":1846,"limit":1000000},"ppgeneratednodes":{"value":0,"limit":1500000},"postexpandincludesize":{"value":99120,"limit":2097152},"templateargumentsize":{"value":5343,"limit":2097152},"expansiondepth":{"value":13,"limit":40},"expensivefunctioncount":{"value":17,"limit":500},"entityaccesscount":{"value":0,"limit":400},"timingprofile":["100.00% 347.788 1 -total"," 18.49% 64.302 1 Template:Pp-protect"," 13.40% 46.603 1 Template:Cite_web"," 12.64% 43.958 1 Template:Policy"," 12.35% 42.935 3 Template:Policy_shortcut"," 11.71% 40.716 1 Template:Ombox"," 10.25% 35.663 8 Template:Navbox"," 7.67% 26.664 3 Template:Bulleted_list"," 7.28% 25.323 1 Template:Wikipedia_policies_and_guidelines"," 6.10% 21.207 1 Template:IPAc-en"]},"scribunto":{"limitreport-timeusage":{"value":"0.148","limit":"10.000"},"limitreport-memusage":{"value":4590159,"limit":52428800}},"cachereport":{"origin":"mw1270","timestamp":"20180221021136","ttl":1900800,"transientcontent":false}}});});(window.RLQ=window.RLQ||[]).push(function(){mw.config.set({"wgBackendResponseTime":89,"wgHostname":"mw1269"});});


Wikipedia:Edit_warring - Photos and All Basic Informations

Wikipedia:Edit_warring More Links

This Page Is Semi-protected.Wikipedia:Wheel WarringWikipedia:Edit ConflictWikipedia:Administrators' Noticeboard/Edit WarringWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:What "Ignore All Rules" MeansWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:ShortcutEnlargeHelp:IPA/EnglishAbout This SoundWikipedia:RevertWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:DRWikipedia:BLOCKWikipedia:BANBright-line RuleHelp:RevertingWikipedia:Gaming The SystemWikipedia:BLPWikipedia:List Of PoliciesWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:Clean StartWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:HarassmentWikipedia:Non-discrimination PolicyWikipedia:No Personal AttacksWikipedia:Ownership Of ContentWikipedia:Sock PuppetryWikipedia:Username PolicyWikipedia:VandalismTemplate:Conduct Policy ListTemplate Talk:Conduct Policy ListWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:Be BoldWikipedia:BRDWikipedia:POVWikipedia:VandalismWikipedia:VandalismWikipedia:BLPWikipedia:BANWikipedia:BLOCKWikipedia:User PagesHelp:Edit SummaryHelp:Talk PageWikipedia:TwinkleWikipedia:HuggleWikipedia:RollbackWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:BLOCKWikipedia:DisruptionBright-line RuleWikipedia:Sock PuppetryWikipedia:Administrators' Noticeboard/Edit WarringWikipedia:UNDOWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:User PageWikipedia:Banning PolicyWikipedia:Alternate AccountWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:VandalismWikipedia:Copyright ViolationsWikipedia:Non-free Content CriteriaWikipedia:Files For DiscussionChild PornographyWikipedia:LINKVIOWikipedia:Biographies Of Living PersonsLibelWikipedia:Biographies Of Living Persons/NoticeboardWikipedia:FAWikipedia:TFAWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:DRWikipedia:Administrators' Noticeboard/Edit WarringWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:Arbitration CommitteeWikipedia:AEWikipedia:Editing RestrictionsWikipedia:General SanctionsWikipedia:Revert Only When NecessaryEnlargeWikipedia:AVOIDEDITWARWikipedia:AN/EWTemplate:Uw-3rrWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:ShortcutWikipedia:Edit SummaryWikipedia:TALKWikipedia:There Is No DeadlineWikipedia:Template Messages/CleanupWikipedia:Third OpinionWikipedia:RFCWikipedia:DRWikipedia:Edit WarringWikipedia:Revert Only When NecessaryWikipedia:ControversialWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Requests For Page ProtectionWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:AdministratorsWikipedia:Administrators' Noticeboard/Edit WarringWikipedia:Arguments To Avoid In Edit WarsWikipedia:BOLD, Revert, Discuss CycleWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Disruptive EditingWikipedia:EtiquetteWikipedia:Lamest Edit WarsWikipedia:Ownership Of ArticlesWikipedia:Page-move WarHelp:RevertingWikipedia:Three-revert RuleWikipedia:RevertingWikipedia:Alternatives To ReversionWikipedia:Baby And BathwaterWikipedia:Revert Only When NecessaryWikipedia:Don't Shoot Yourself In The FootWikipedia:Sock PuppetryHelp:Talkspace DraftWikipedia:Tendentious EditingPLoS ONETemplate:Wikipedia Policies And GuidelinesTemplate Talk:Wikipedia Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:Five PillarsWikipedia:What Wikipedia Is NotWikipedia:Ignore All RulesWikipedia:VerifiabilityWikipedia:No Original ResearchWikipedia:Neutral Point Of ViewWikipedia:What Wikipedia Is NotWikipedia:Biographies Of Living PersonsWikipedia:Image Use PolicyWikipedia:Wikipedia Is Not A DictionaryWikipedia:Article TitlesWikipedia:NotabilityWikipedia:AutobiographyWikipedia:Citing SourcesWikipedia:Identifying Reliable SourcesWikipedia:Identifying Reliable Sources (medicine)Wikipedia:Do Not Include The Full Text Of Lengthy Primary SourcesWikipedia:PlagiarismWikipedia:Do Not Create HoaxesWikipedia:Fringe TheoriesWikipedia:Patent NonsenseWikipedia:External LinksWikipedia:CivilityWikipedia:ConsensusWikipedia:Editing PolicyWikipedia:HarassmentWikipedia:VandalismWikipedia:Ignore All RulesWikipedia:No Personal AttacksWikipedia:Ownership Of ContentWikipedia:Dispute ResolutionWikipedia:Sock PuppetryWikipedia:No Legal ThreatsWikipedia:Child ProtectionWikipedia:Paid-contribution DisclosureWikipedia:Assume Good FaithWikipedia:Conflict Of InterestWikipedia:Disruptive EditingWikipedia:Do Not Disrupt Wikipedia To Illustrate A PointWikipedia:EtiquetteWikipedia:Gaming The SystemWikipedia:Please Do Not Bite The NewcomersWikipedia:Courtesy VanishingWikipedia:Deletion PolicyWikipedia:Proposed DeletionWikipedia:Criteria For Speedy DeletionWikipedia:Attack PageWikipedia:OversightWikipedia:Proposed Deletion Of Biographies Of Living PeopleWikipedia:Proposed Deletion (books)Wikipedia:Revision DeletionWikipedia:AdministratorsWikipedia:Banning PolicyWikipedia:Blocking PolicyWikipedia:Protection PolicyWikipedia:Article SizeWikipedia:Be BoldWikipedia:DisambiguationWikipedia:HatnoteWikipedia:Set Index ArticlesWikipedia:SubpagesWikipedia:User PagesWikipedia:Talk Page GuidelinesWikipedia:SignaturesWikipedia:Broad-concept ArticleWikipedia:Project NamespaceWikipedia:WikiProject Council/GuideWikipedia:Manual Of StyleWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ContentsWikipedia:Manual Of Style/AccessibilityWikipedia:Make Technical Articles UnderstandableWikipedia:Manual Of Style/Dates And NumbersWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ImagesWikipedia:Manual Of Style/LayoutWikipedia:Manual Of Style/Lead SectionWikipedia:Manual Of Style/LinkingWikipedia:Manual Of Style/ListsWikipedia:Categories, Lists, And Navigation TemplatesWikipedia:CategorizationWikipedia:Template NamespaceWikipedia:List Of Policies And GuidelinesWikipedia:List Of PoliciesWikipedia:List Of GuidelinesWikipedia:PrinciplesHelp:CategoryCategory:Wikipedia PoliciesCategory:Wikipedia:Edit WarringCategory:Wikipedia Semi-protected Project PagesCategory:Wikipedia Move-protected Project PagesCategory:Articles Including Recorded Pronunciations (English)Discussion About Edits From This IP Address [n]A List Of Edits Made From This IP Address [y]View The Project Page [c]Discussion About The Content Page [t]This Page Is Protected. You Can View Its Source [e]Visit The Main Page [z]Guides To Browsing WikipediaFeatured Content – The Best Of WikipediaFind Background Information On Current EventsLoad A Random Article [x]Guidance On How To Use And Edit WikipediaFind Out About WikipediaAbout The Project, What You Can Do, Where To Find ThingsA List Of Recent Changes In The Wiki [r]List Of All English Wikipedia Pages Containing Links To This Page [j]Recent Changes In Pages Linked From This Page [k]Upload Files [u]A List Of All Special Pages [q]Wikipedia:AboutWikipedia:General Disclaimer



view link view link view link view link view link